An Amazon EC2 administrator created the following policy associated with an IAM group containing several users:
What is the effect of this policy?
An Amazon EC2 administrator created the following policy associated with an IAM group containing several users:
What is the effect of this policy?
The policy contains two statements: the first one allows EC2 instance termination actions for users within the IP range 10.100.100.0/24, and the second one denies all EC2 actions outside the us-east-1 region. Combining these two rules results in the ability of users to terminate EC2 instances in the us-east-1 region only if their IP falls within the specified range, which includes 10.100.100.254.
What the policy means: 1. Allow termination of any instance if user’s source IP address is 100.100.254. 2. Deny termination of instances that are not in the us-east-1 Combining this two, you get: “Allow instance termination in the us-east-1 region if the user’s source IP address is 10.100.100.254. Deny termination operation on other regions.”
Nice explanation. Thanks
C is correct. 0.0/24 , the following five IP addresses are reserved: 0.0: Network address. 0.1: Reserved by AWS for the VPC router. 0.2: Reserved by AWS. The IP address of the DNS server is the base of the VPC network range plus two. ... 0.3: Reserved by AWS for future use. 0.255: Network broadcast address.
A good explanation!
if IP = 10.100.100.0/24 allow terminate EC2 Else Deny EC2 termination permission - with the condition "String NOT equal" to us-east-1 Answer C
Clearly the answer is C. D is 'Deny' 'String NOT equal' == only allow us-east-1
Deny takes precedence over Allow. Thus the flow is as follows: IF region of the EC2 instance is not "us-east-1" -> Deny ELSE if request is coming from 10.100.100.0/24 -> Allow ELSE: implicit deny (what is not allowed is denied)
Here is how I interpreted this first part: terminate instance is allowed for the given CIDR block second part: deny all ec2 actions when region is not us-east-1 so second part is like double negative which means allow for us-east-1 region You combine both (remember deny always take priority which is why this is written in double negative) and you get: [allow us-east-region1 to do any action on ec2] when [action is terminate instance and CIDR block is match] so C is the answer D is there to confuse you with the double negative
The first rule allows users with the specified IP CIDR to terminate instances, and the second rule specifies that the region must be us-east-1 for the termination process to be allowed, hence C is the correct answer.
policy allow us-east-1 and with the specific IP address in the range
C for sure
D. Users cannot terminate an EC2 instance in the us-east-1 region when the user's source IP is 10.100.100.254. This option corresponds to the second statement in the policy, where all EC2 actions in the "us-east-1" region are denied permission when the user's source IP is "10.100.100.254".
but it says "StringNotEquals" meaning everything is denied apart from us-east-1
The first statement allows users to terminate EC2 instances (ec2:TerminateInstances) from any IP address within the range 10.100.100.0/24. The second statement denies users the ability to perform any EC2 actions (ec2:*) in any region other than us-east-1. So, the correct interpretation is: D. Users cannot terminate an EC2 instance in the us-east-1 Region when the user's source IP is 10.100.100.254
D denies "the ability to perform any actions in any region OTHER than us-east-1". Thus the user CAN terminate instances IN us-east-1. Thus C.
C because the explicit deny blocks other regions than us-east-1
The first statement is a subset of the second statement.
ans D - This policy denies EC2 instance termination for users with the source IP address 10.100.100.254 in the us-east-1 Region.
D is not because of Deny & NOT Equals
I went for C for obvious reasons Wondering though; this policy also allows to terminate EC2 instances in US-east-1 even if your source IP is not the 10.100.100.254, right? The idea is that since I do not deny this for the other source IP addresses, the Allow action is a obsolete?
Deny all actions on the EC2 instances in the us-east1 region, but let anyone with source IP 10.100.100.254 be able to terminate the EC2 instances.